Slowtwitch.com Main Index MAIN
INDEX
Forum Rules & Legend RULES &
LEGEND
Log in LOG
IN
 
 
 
Search for (options)
Newsletter Signup

Slowtwitch Forums: Lavender Room:
Wesley Clark

 

First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next page Last page  View All Tri ForumClassifiedsLavender RoomJobsThe Womens


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 9:35

Post #151 of 192 (285 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Slowman] [In reply to] Can't Post

Victoria Secrets has 20% off right now.

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


trio_jeepy

Jul 2, 08 9:37

Post #152 of 192 (282 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Slowman] [In reply to] Can't Post

I think the interesting bias here is that while most people would argue that the Navy's records and its testimony in support of Kerry would represent the default position, and therefore the burden of proof is squarely upon anybody who disagrees. Yet I think its telling that some people have turned this on its head, arguing that Kerry needs to disprove them, despite the fact that they have no physical evidence in their favor and can't dispute the Navy. Evidently, the rules of logic don't apply when you're bashing Democrats.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"They who would give up an essential liberty for temporary security, deserve neither liberty or security" - Benjamin Franklin
"Don't you see the rest of the country looks upon New York like we're left-wing, communist, Jewish, homosexual pornographers? I think of us that way sometimes and I live here." - Alvy Singer, "Annie Hall"


slowbern

Jul 2, 08 9:37

Post #153 of 192 (281 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Casey] [In reply to] Can't Post

Was Obama supposed to help you? How has Clinton, as a Senator in New York helped you?

No, Senator Obama was not really supposed to help me. The statement I made was a direct answer to MattinSF who claimed that Senator Obama has "worked to help the poor and workers" as a community organizer. I consider myself to be a worker. I am a member of a labor union. Senator Clinton has actually been a strong supporter of fire fighter issues in Congress (both union and non-union) like the SAFER act. These are issues that have required bi-partisan support and coalition building (which is not something that Senator Obama has really shown a flair for in 3 years as a Senator). Senator McCain has shown aptitude in the same way actually, although he is not quite as labor-friendly in other regards. I personally do not look at a candidate (especially at the national level) that I support only on how it affects my work. Although that figures into it.

So you think he thinks he is better than you because of his education.

Yes.

You are kidding right?

No. Clearly Senator Obama does not know me personally. But I definitely get the sense that he would have no problem being condescending to me. Guess what, some people who get educations are this way. It is a sense that I get from people that they are too good to do what I do, too good to get their hands dirty. I know several people in my life who aren't this way who have PhD's. My ideas would be marginalized because it comes from the experiential and hands-on rather than the academic. My brother (who coincidentally is a community organizer in Chicago) is this way. So is my sister, who is a labor attorney.

I get the sense that Senator Obama would come to ask me a question, because he has to. But he would probably just do what he thinks is best because he is "smarter" than me.

how have those turned out for you?

Altogether, just fine.

Bernie


_______________

There, Sphere, are you happy?


dave_w

Jul 2, 08 9:38

Post #154 of 192 (280 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Slowman] [In reply to] Can't Post

   One thing that the swift boaters caused was even more info about Kerry's Vietnam time to be put out there (we may see the same on McCain). I could never buy into the swiftboat appeals, because at the time it seemed too much of a he-said she-said affair. Apart from the main theme that they were trying to sink him with, some of the little stuff was verifiable, and made an impact on me. Those tidbits included some out of the ordinary things like putting himself in for purple hearts. I was also personally struck that he seemed to approach the whole thing as a photo-op, having specific video taken of him doing things, and looking Kennedy-esque.

"It's all about self-esteem"


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 9:51

Post #155 of 192 (276 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [dave_w] [In reply to] Can't Post

http://campaignspot.nationalreview.com/...hNDJiNGZhNzg0NTI4MmM=

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


MattinSF

Jul 2, 08 9:59

Post #156 of 192 (270 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [slowbern] [In reply to] Can't Post

Bernie you clearly have a big chip on your shoulder.

Did your parents refuse to pay for college or something? Did you have to go to Podunkville Community College when all your buddies were heading off to State to party with coeds? Is this why you don't like educated people?
----------------------------------------------------------
HOPE is a plan that worked. CHANGE is a plan that worked. BELIEVE is a plan that worked.


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 10:06

Post #157 of 192 (264 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [MattinSF] [In reply to] Can't Post

LOL. Matt, you are demonstrating elitism. Instead of listening to what Bernie says, you mock him and infer he doesn't know what he is talking about.

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


slowbern

Jul 2, 08 10:08

Post #158 of 192 (262 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [MattinSF] [In reply to] Can't Post

Bernie you clearly have a big chip on your shoulder.

Did your parents refuse to pay for college or something? Did you have to go to Podunkville Community College when all your buddies were heading off to State to party with coeds? Is this why you don't like educated people?


My parents paid for college the first time around. I dropped out and went to work and paid them back. I went back a few years later and tried to fund it on my own, but I couldn't manage it at the time (money wise or time wise). I am back in college for the 3rd time in 18 years...hopefully I'll finish. I'm paying it for myself.

I like educated people just fine. It is their attitudes that I don't like. Often it is like when you hire a new kid who has all of the answers without ever having done a day's work. So if that is a "chip on my shoulder" than I suppose I'm guilty as charged.

Bernie


_______________

There, Sphere, are you happy?


MattinSF

Jul 2, 08 10:17

Post #159 of 192 (251 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [last tri in 83] [In reply to] Can't Post


In Reply To
LOL. Matt, you are demonstrating elitism. Instead of listening to what Bernie says, you mock him and infer he doesn't know what he is talking about.

  If being elitist is pointing out reverse snobbery when I see it then I too am guilty as charged.
----------------------------------------------------------
HOPE is a plan that worked. CHANGE is a plan that worked. BELIEVE is a plan that worked.


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 10:20

Post #160 of 192 (248 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [MattinSF] [In reply to] Can't Post

Priceless.

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


sphere

Jul 2, 08 10:27

Post #161 of 192 (237 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [slowbern] [In reply to] Can't Post

Your impression is a common perception held by us blue collar types (and it may very well be true to some extent, I don't know), but aside from the media pushing the idea and the juxtapositional personas (Bush=hayseed, McCain=G.I.Joe), what is it exactly that lends support to your opinion that he would look down his nose at people like us, considering his upbringing and history of serving the poor?



"The nice part about being a pessimist is that you are constantly being either proven right or pleasantly surprised." - George F. Will


LorenzoP

Jul 2, 08 10:31

Post #162 of 192 (226 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [sphere] [In reply to] Can't Post

 

BTW, has any General, or anyone with credentials presented a view opposite of Clark's - - that McCain does have the experience and has shown sufficient judgment to warrant McCain's claim he is qualified?


MattinSF

Jul 2, 08 10:31

Post #163 of 192 (226 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [last tri in 83] [In reply to] Can't Post


In Reply To
Priceless.

 
I'm thinking of changing my tag line, what do you think??

"I like educated people just fine. It is their attitudes that I don't like."
----------------------------------------------------------
HOPE is a plan that worked. CHANGE is a plan that worked. BELIEVE is a plan that worked.


Slowman

Jul 2, 08 10:36

Post #164 of 192 (221 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [dave_w] [In reply to] Can't Post

"I could never buy into the swiftboat appeals, because at the time it seemed too much of a he-said she-said affair."

as trio jeepy pointed out, the swiftboat appeals were not he-said, she-said. it was he-said versus the-navy-said, the-eyewitnesses-said, the-crew-members-said. granting it she-said status is buying into the partisan bullshit. you saw precisely what you wanted to see. you were given a free pass to vote your bias by the swiftboaters, and you took it.

there is one take-away from the swiftboat affair that was in any way telling on the candidates themselves, and that is that george bush stood by and let it happen, arguably even giving them a pat on the back and saying, 'you go, boys!' john mccain would never have stood for that, not in a million years. that's the difference between george bush and john mccain. personally, i'd be ashamed to admit it if the swiftboaters had gotten me to vote the way they wanted.


Dan Empfield
aka Slowman


Tri N OC

Jul 2, 08 10:37

Post #165 of 192 (220 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [sphere] [In reply to] Can't Post

what is it exactly that lends support to your opinion that he would look down his nose at people like us, considering his upbringing and history of serving the poor?

I get what Bernie is saying. As for quantifying it, I fall back on Justice Potter Stewart: ". . .I know it when I see it."

I have listened to the prepared speeches, interviews and talks with the voters, it shines through for me. In addition, I don't necessarily think it is a disqualifying trait.


Tridiot

Jul 2, 08 10:41

Post #166 of 192 (217 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [slowguy] [In reply to] Can't Post

Whether you were or were not for Bush, the whole "I feel like I could sit down and have a beer with him" stuff was totally horrific in 2000 and 2004. The "home spun folksy down to earth guy" thing worked, and it was brilliant from a strategy standpoint (especially given the stiffs he was running against).

I am with you on what I look for in a President.


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 10:41

Post #167 of 192 (217 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [MattinSF] [In reply to] Can't Post

That's funny, I was thinking of grabbing your reverse snobbery quote.

In your defense Matt, although you are an unapologetic filthy liberal, you are more a man of the people than most I encounter. I could see you going to a NASCAR race (if someone gave you free tickets) and drinking American beer while woofing down hot dogs.

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


last tri in 83

Jul 2, 08 10:45

Post #168 of 192 (213 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Slowman] [In reply to] Can't Post

My hypertension medicated brain is not as sharp as it usd to be but I do remember Bush coming out against the Swiftboat ads. I'm sure he really didn't mean it, though.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5797164/

_____________________________________________
Conservative in exile.


Old and Haggard

Jul 2, 08 10:47

Post #169 of 192 (209 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [ajfranke] [In reply to] Can't Post

http://www.nytimes.com/...ft%20boat&st=cse
http://www.nytimes.com/...28_KERR_GRAPHIC.html
http://www.nytimes.com/...ft%20boat&st=cse:



Quote

The veterans group, led by Mr. O'Neill, a former Swift boat commander who was recruited by the Nixon administration to debate Mr. Kerry on "The Dick Cavett Show" in 1971, began its campaign in early 2004 by criticizing Mr. Kerry's protests against the Vietnam War. But backed by Republican donors and consultants, they soon shifted to attack his greatest strength — his record as a military hero in a campaign against a president who never went to war.

Naval records and accounts from other sailors contradicted almost every claim they made, and some members of the group who had earlier praised Mr. Kerry's heroism contradicted themselves.

 

Quote

Some of Mr. Kerry's friends and former Swift boat crew members made advertisements during the race to try to shoot down the group's charges. But the campaign declined to air them widely because some strategists said that directly challenging the charges would legitimize them.
They approached Mr. Kerry after the election with the idea of setting the record straight.
So they have returned, for instance, to the question of Cambodia and whether Mr. Kerry was ever ordered to transport Navy Seals across the border, an experience that he said made him view government officials, who had declared that the country was not part of the war, as deceptive.
The Swift boat group insisted that no boats had gone to Cambodia. But Mr. Kerry's researcher, using Vietnam-era military maps and spot reports from the naval archives showing coordinates for his boat, traced his path from Ha Tien toward Cambodia on a mission that records say was to insert Navy Seals

 
I'm sure it's just a coincidence, but is William Franke, one of the SBVT founders, any relation of yours?


Quote

Mr. Kerry's defenders have received help from unlikely sources, including some who were originally aligned with the Swift boat group but later objected to its accusations against Mr. Kerry. One of them, Steve Hayes, was an early member of the group. A former sailor, he was a longtime friend and employee of William Franke, one of the group's founders, and he supported the push to have Mr. Kerry release his military files. But Mr. Hayes came to believe that the group was twisting Mr. Kerry's record.

"The mantra was just 'We want to set the record straight,' " Mr. Hayes said this month. "It became clear to me that it was morphing from an organization to set the record straight into a highly political vendetta. They knew it was not the truth."

Mr. Hayes broke with the group, ending a 35-year friendship with Mr. Franke, and voted for Mr. Kerry. He has provided a long interview to Mr. Kerry's supporters, backing their version of the incident for which Mr. Kerry received the Bronze Star.

  -----------------------------------
Ken Lehner

"reread klenher [sic] and pretty much skip the rest." - desert dude 5/25/2008


Old and Haggard

Jul 2, 08 10:52

Post #170 of 192 (195 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [trio_jeepy] [In reply to] Can't Post

It's the reverse of the college slut who slept with everyone on the football team, who becomes a virginal character worthy of respect once your frat president is going steady with her.
-----------------------------------
Ken Lehner

"reread klenher [sic] and pretty much skip the rest." - desert dude 5/25/2008


Old and Haggard

Jul 2, 08 10:55

Post #171 of 192 (190 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [ajfranke] [In reply to] Can't Post


In Reply To
He served his country well by all accounts that I have read. I wasn't on a gunboat. He is way ahead of me on that score.

And again:

Not to brownnose, but I have to second the Slowman. Kerry was on the gunboat in Vietnam, even if it was only for four months. I wasn't. He gets my respect for that.

And again in 2005:

Kerry was on that gunboat, and I never was. That puts him way ahead of me regardless of any after the fact details.

And yet again in 2006. I am nothing if not consistent:

I don't know what happened in that gunboat. I wasn't there, and I don't really care since Kerry gets an A in my book for ever being in that boat despite the fact it was only for a three month tour and despite the fact he tried mightly to avoid it.

  Have you heard the phrase "damning with faint praise"?
-----------------------------------
Ken Lehner

"reread klenher [sic] and pretty much skip the rest." - desert dude 5/25/2008


trio_jeepy

Jul 2, 08 10:56

Post #172 of 192 (188 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [klehner] [In reply to] Can't Post

Or the fuckabout playboy drunk partyboy who "finds God" and quits drinking who draws more esteem than decorated war veterans without the good sense to acquire a substance problem and conquer it.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"They who would give up an essential liberty for temporary security, deserve neither liberty or security" - Benjamin Franklin
"Don't you see the rest of the country looks upon New York like we're left-wing, communist, Jewish, homosexual pornographers? I think of us that way sometimes and I live here." - Alvy Singer, "Annie Hall"


LorenzoP

Jul 2, 08 11:06

Post #173 of 192 (181 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [klehner] [In reply to] Can't Post

what the right wing does - and Art is keeping with the tradition - - is raise doubt via false facts or wild ass opinions - and by doing so appealing to the most base of human emotions.

and Lee Altwater developed to technique back in the 80's


Old and Haggard

Jul 2, 08 11:08

Post #174 of 192 (179 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [last tri in 83] [In reply to] Can't Post


In Reply To
My hypertension medicated brain is not as sharp as it usd to be but I do remember Bush coming out against the Swiftboat ads. I'm sure he really didn't mean it, though.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5797164/

 
Sweet mother of God, did you actually read the article you linked?


Quote

CRAWFORD, Texas - President Bush on Monday criticized a commercial that accused John Kerry of inflating his own Vietnam War record, more than a week after the ad stopped running, and said broadcast attacks by outside groups have no place in the race for the White House.
“I think they’re bad for the system,” added Bush, who had ignored calls to condemn the ad while it was on the air.

  At best, Bush was criticizing outside attack ads in general, and not the SBVT ads in particular. Most likely, he refused to do the honorable thing and lapped up the damage these ads did to Kerry.
-----------------------------------
Ken Lehner

"reread klenher [sic] and pretty much skip the rest." - desert dude 5/25/2008


JSA

Jul 2, 08 11:16

Post #175 of 192 (170 views)
Re: Wesley Clark [Slowman] [In reply to] Can't Post

to bring this full circle, one must ask whether wesley clark's comments on face the nation were swiftboat-like, or whether they were fair, or whether they were fair but inartfully expressed. i rather think the last of the three options, but reasonable people can disagree.

I have said a couple times before and I will say it again -- Wesley Clark is/was an amazing military leader but, Wesley Clark is/was a horrible, inept, inartful speaker. This fantastic flaw in an otherwise impressive package cost him his job, his command, and, in part, his reputation. To put it simply, he stepped on his dick in Kosovo and he is doing it again.

Were they swiftboat-like? No way. Not even close. That was a full-blown smear campaign.

Were they fair and artfully expressed? Nope. He stepped on his dick again. IMO, he did not intend to degrade McCain's military service, but, that is how it came off and is why Obama had to distance himself.

Were they fair and inartfully expressed? Inartfully expressed, yes. Fair? Not in my book only b/c of the way they were presented. I said before, it is called "selfless service." Military service is what it is. The servicemember should not make too much of it and no one has the right to demean it (which is why the swift-boat thing truly offended me even though I cannot stand John Kerry).


_______________________________________________

"My better is better than your better." - LT, via Nike

The people who keep me moving:

TRANSITION - Get Moving!


First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next page Last page  View All